Now that we have discussed what bearing pressure in foundations is, we can move to another side of the same coin— Loss of Contact in Foundations.
When a building transfers load to the soil, we typically assume that the entire base of the foundation remains in full contact with the ground.
But in real-world conditions, especially under eccentric vertical loads, lateral forces/moments, tension, or seismic actions, this may not happen.What is Loss of Contact?
In simple explanation,
Part of the footing stops touching the ground due to uneven loading.
When moment acts, one edge compresses and the other lifts. If vertical compressive load is not sufficiently large to keep the lifted region in compression, Loss of Contact occurs.
Due to this, the remaining soil in contact now carries all the load, causing redistribution of bearing pressure on the foundation. This phenomenon is explored in detail in Teng’s “Foundation Design”.
Why does Loss of Contact Occurs?
1. Eccentric LoadingSometimes the vertical load acts away from the centerline of the column and this causes a non-uniform soil pressure distribution (a moment is introduced due to eccentricity).
This non-uniform distribution can cause Loss of Contact.
2. Overturning Moment
Sometimes lateral loads like wind, seismic, or machine loads can cause the foundation to overturn and push one side down while lifting the other resulting in Loss of Contact.
3. Lateral Loads on Block Foundations
These are part of the Dynamic Forces on Equipment Foundations. Basically, due to presence of Unbalanced Forces on rotating equipment (due to uneven balancing of mass) some uplift can occur leading to Loss of Contact.
4. Rigid Footing Assumption
With linear pressure distribution, any negative pressure value at the edge is interpreted as tension which results in Loss of Contact. (Refer Bearing in Concrete Foundation Design)
How Loss of Contact Affects Foundations?
Modification in Bearing PressureDue to loss of contact, the bearing pressure gets modified due to change in pressure distribution as well as reduction in available bearing area.
Nonlinear Soil Response
The Loss in Contact can also change the assumed Rigid Body Assumption to fail by creating a local zone of high bending/curving of the footing.
Reduced Sliding Resistance
Sliding is directly linked to the compressive normal force on the footing. If the compressive force reduces, sliding resistance also reduces. (More on this in the upcoming blog on Sliding Failure in Foundations).
More Settlement for Compressive Zone
Stress concentration on one side due to Loss of Contact may cause local settlement in that region, tilting the structure further.
How Engineers Check Loss of Contact in Practice?
Bearing Pressure Equations
The linear distribution of bearing pressure can be used to check Loss of Contact too. If any area has negative or zero bearing pressure, we can say that the area is under Loss of Contact.
(Refer Bearing in Concrete Foundation Design)
Middle Kern Rule
Any footing can be exposed to vertical loadings along with lateral loadings. The moments can be expressed in the form of eccentricity to the centerline of the footing (refer figure above), and this leads us to the middle kern rule.
If the eccentricity caused by the moments is within the kern (middle third), no Loss of Contact occurs and if it is outside, Loss of Contact is present.
If eccentricity exceeds half the footing dimension, the resultant lies outside the footing and foundation is theoretically unstable.
It is a graphical approach to the Bearing pressure equation method.
Soil Spring Models
In FEM Analysis, each node can be modelled as a spring of stiffness similar to the stiffness of soil in that region. This spring will compress (use springs as compression-only) on application of load.
Springs with tensile reactions have uplift whereas springs with zero or negative reaction make the Loss of Contact Zone.
Is Loss of Contact Always Bad?
No.
Controlled uplift is acceptable if it is small and within specified percentages of the total area (usually less than 20% of area)
Only if the uplift area is too large, that makes the foundation unstable or overstressed can cause trouble.
How to Reduce or Avoid Loss of Contact?
Increase Footing SizeThis reduces eccentricity of the Load and Distributes the pressure on the larger area resulting in lesser Loss of Contact
Add Tie Beams or Grade Beams
Beams help in distribution of loads between various foundations and thus reduces chances of isolated uplift.
Mat or Deep Foundation instead of Isolated Footings
Mats and piles can handle moments and uplift better than isolated footings.
Increase Dead Load
Increases overall compression on the soil and reduces uplift
Calculation for Loss of Contact Check:
1. Kern Check
If we considered the same footing now with only the axial load acting at some eccentricity in X and Y directions, the Bending Pressure can be written as,
Bearing Pressure =
Comparing both equations we get,
Mx =
My =
For no loss of contact, Bearing Pressure > 0.
on simplifying we get
This can be plotted on the cross section of the column to get the region where if resultant eccentricity of loads occurs, no loss of contact will occur.
Also, if the eccentricity more than the half of column edge sizes, the point of loading lies outside the column, and the foundation is considered to have theoretically flipped and unstable.
2. Bearing Pressure Equations
Final Thoughts:
Next, we will discuss:
Stay Tuned.
this was really helpful in understanding the concept of loss of contact. the diagrams were comprehensive yet easy to understand. thank you
ReplyDelete